In my years of judging OM competitions, I've seen many
teams make mistakes that they could easily have avoided.
Here's my list of the most common and costly ones.
- Incorrect or incomprehensible style forms
- Many teams don't understand style, and fill out
the style forms incorrectly, or worse,
incomprehensibly. Style is the elaboration of the
problem solution, which means you can put down
for scoring anything you do that add to or
embellishes the solution to the problem. Many
teams don't think about what their strongest
areas are, and put down something ambiguous like
'Costumes'. What about the costumes? What aspect
of them makes them special?
A very common
error is to duplicate items already scored in the
problem. For instance, an Omerdroid team will put
down 'Humor of the performance'. When this
happens, I have to ask them to change the style
forms while they're standing there in the staging
area.
For some problems, teams have to submit an
extra sheet of paper describing some aspect of
their solution. In Omerdroid, this was a list of
actions the robot would do. Some teams confuse
this list with the style form, and put their
actions on the style form.
Many teams handwrite the style forms, or make
bad photocopies, or write very long, unclear
descriptions of their presentation in the box at
the bottom. The judges will only have about three
minutes to read this. If they can't understand
what you've written, they'll ignore it, to the
detriment of your team.
- Not having read the rules thoroughly
- I've seen so many teams lose points because they,
or their coaches, obviously haven't read the
rules. Coaches have asserted to me that the
tournament director must provide an extension
cord, but I then I show them the rulebook (and
ask another team if they could lend them one).
Teams don't put the right information on their
membership sign, or don't understand outside
assistance. Teams will tell me of people who
quit, and the new people who took their places.
Please
make sure to read the rulebook and the problems
thoroughly. One team at a recent competition
entered one problem but solved a different one!
- Making unwarranted assumptions about the
performance room
- Assume the worst. Assume the plugs will be far
away and you'll need a very long extension cord.
If your team needs a hard floor, assume
carpeting. If you need carpeting, assume a hard
floor. Assume a standard doorway.
I've seen
many teams who panicked because they forgot to
bring an extension cord, or it wasn't long
enough, or they couldn't turn off the lights, or
the judges table was facing the wrong way, or the
performance area wasn't big enough.
- Not talking loud enough, clear enough, or slow
enough
- Performances often take place in gyms, with awful
acoustics, or loud fans blowing in the
background. Teams often mumble their lines, lines
of a script that's already too complicated to be
understood by watching it only once.
-
- Staying up the night before
- An OM solution is not something you want to do at
the last minute. The best teams will have taken
their time, and it shows in their presentations.
Get a good night's sleep so you can enjoy the day
ahead.
|